I Replaced All My Non-Stick Pans With Caraway -- Here's the Honest Truth

The Pan Situation That Started This

I was using the same non-stick skillet I'd had for six years when I noticed it had scratches deep enough that the coating was visibly flaking. I'd been cooking on that for years.

That was the moment I went down the PFAS rabbit hole. PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) are the chemicals used in traditional non-stick coatings like PTFE (Teflon). At normal cooking temperatures they're generally stable, but once a non-stick pan is scratched or damaged, coating particles and chemicals can get into food. The research on PFAS accumulation in human tissue is genuinely concerning.

I replaced everything. After testing Caraway, GreenPan, and Made In, here's where I landed.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I earn a small commission on qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

What Caraway Is (and Isn't)

Caraway makes ceramic-coated aluminum cookware. The ceramic coating is mineral-based and free of PFAS, PTFE, lead, and cadmium. This is a meaningful distinction -- "ceramic" does not automatically mean non-toxic (some ceramic coatings contain concerning compounds). Caraway's formulation has been independently tested.

The coating is not as non-stick as Teflon. Let's be honest about this: nothing is as slippery as fresh Teflon. Ceramic is good non-stick that requires slightly more care, but it's significantly more durable than traditional non-stick and it doesn't degrade in the same dangerous way.

What Caraway does well:

• Genuinely non-stick for eggs, fish, and other delicate foods when used with light oil
• Even heat distribution (aluminum core conducts well)
• Oven safe to 550°F
• Dishwasher safe (though hand washing extends the coating life)
• Beautiful aesthetic -- the colors are legitimately gorgeous

The 4-Piece Set: One Year Later

I bought the Caraway 4-piece cookware set (4.5 qt sauté pan, 10.5-inch fry pan, 3 qt sauce pan, 6.5 qt Dutch oven) plus the lid storage organizer. Here's how each piece has held up:

10.5" Fry Pan: My most-used piece. The coating is still excellent after a year -- eggs slide out perfectly, nothing sticks with a small amount of oil. This is the one I was most worried about and it's held up better than expected.

4.5 qt Sauté Pan: My favorite piece in the set. The walls are high enough for sauces and braises, the surface area is wide enough for searing. Genuinely versatile.

3 qt Sauce Pan: Does what it should. I use this for everything from oatmeal to soups to sauces.

6.5 qt Dutch Oven: I use this 3-4 times a week. The ceramic Dutch oven is lighter than cast iron (not a small thing when lifting a full pot), heats evenly, and looks beautiful going from stovetop to table.

How to Make the Coating Last

The biggest mistake people make with ceramic cookware is using it on high heat without oil. Ceramic needs a small amount of fat to maintain its non-stick properties. I use avocado oil spray or a small pat of butter on every cook.

Rules I follow:

1. Preheat on medium, not high
2. Always add a small amount of fat before food
3. Never use metal utensils -- silicone or wood only
4. Hand wash with non-abrasive sponge (no steel wool, no harsh scrubbing)
5. Let it cool before washing -- thermal shock can damage the coating

Following these, my pans look nearly new after 12 months of daily cooking.

The Competition

GreenPan: Comparable technology, lower price, but the coating quality is noticeably less premium. The pans work, but the coating starts showing wear earlier. Good budget option if Caraway is out of reach.

Made In: The stainless steel line from Made In is exceptional -- I have two pieces. But stainless requires more technique (proper preheating, oil, temperature management) and isn't right for delicate eggs or fish. Caraway is better for everyday non-stick cooking; Made In is better for high-heat searing.

Cast iron: Excellent for certain things (searing, cornbread, camping), not a daily driver for most people. I kept my Lodge cast iron skillet alongside the Caraway.

Also worth reading: For a completely non-toxic kitchen, pair Caraway cookware with Branch Basics non-toxic cleaners.

The Bottom Line

If you're still cooking on scratched or aging non-stick pans, replace them. That part is non-negotiable.

Whether you replace them with Caraway specifically depends on your budget and cooking habits. If you cook daily, care about what you're eating, and want cookware that looks good and lasts -- Caraway is the best ceramic non-stick option I've tested. The price is real, but it's also the last set of non-stick pans I expect to buy for a very long time.